News · · 7 min read

Can a House Under Contract Be Sold to Another Buyer?

Learn if a house under contract can be sold to someone else.

Can a House Under Contract Be Sold to Another Buyer?

Introduction

Entering into a contract on a home is a critical step in the property transaction process, indicating that a seller has agreed to a buyer's offer. However, this stage can open up a complex legal territory, as demonstrated by a recent case on the Gold Coast where a house was sold for $2.66 million at auction, following a protracted five-year court battle.

It's important to understand that a successful transfer of property ownership hinges on the proper conveyance of the title. Without it, as in the case of Jess and Jackie Morecroft who purchased a house only to find out the title was never legally theirs, buyers can face significant turmoil and loss.

The Morecrofts' ordeal, which resulted in the Supreme Court ruling that they never owned the property due to a blocked title transfer, underlines the necessity of ensuring all legalities are meticulously addressed when a property is under contract. The housing market also reflects the critical nature of these considerations; for instance, the seasonally-adjusted estimate of new houses for sale at the end of October was 439,000, representing a 7.8-month supply at the current sales rate, with the median sales price of new houses sold being $409,300 and the average sales price at $487,000. This data underscores the value and competitive nature of real estate transactions, highlighting why every contractual detail must be managed with precision to secure a successful purchase and avoid the pitfalls of legal disputes and potential loss of investment.

Understanding House Under Contract

Entering into a contract on a home is a critical step in the property transaction process, indicating that a seller has agreed to a buyer's offer. However, this stage can open up a complex legal territory, as demonstrated by a recent case on the Gold Coast where a house was sold for $2.66 million at auction, following a protracted five-year court battle.

It's important to understand that a successful transfer of property ownership hinges on the proper conveyance of the title. Without it, as in the case of Jess and Jackie Morecroft who purchased a house only to find out the title was never legally theirs, buyers can face significant turmoil and loss.

The Morecrofts' ordeal, which resulted in the Supreme Court ruling that they never owned the property due to a blocked title transfer, underlines the necessity of ensuring all legalities are meticulously addressed when a property is under contract. The housing market also reflects the critical nature of these considerations; for instance, the seasonally-adjusted estimate of new houses for sale at the end of October was 439,000, representing a 7.8-month supply at the current sales rate, with the median sales price of new houses sold being $409,300 and the average sales price at $487,000. This data underscores the value and competitive nature of real estate transactions, highlighting why every contractual detail must be managed with precision to secure a successful purchase and avoid the pitfalls of legal disputes and potential loss of investment.

The Contingency Period

The contingency period is a crucial phase in the home-buying process, where you, as a buyer, have the chance to thoroughly vet the property. This period allows you to schedule and conduct a home inspection, a step that should not be overlooked.

Even in a seller's market where inventory is low, it's critical to ensure the property is in good condition. A home inspection can uncover serious issues, providing you with the information needed to negotiate with the seller for repairs or even to adjust the offer price.

It's a protective measure that can save you from unexpected costs in the future. Besides inspections, this period is also the time to secure your financing and delve into the property's details.

You should review the seller's disclosure statement for any red flags and confirm that all necessary building permits for previous work were obtained. Transparency from all parties involved is key to a successful transaction.

Your real estate agent can be a valuable resource during this time, helping to coordinate the various evaluations and navigating any potential risks. Real estate transactions can include several types of contingencies, but they're all designed to protect your interests. Whether it's ensuring that a mortgage can be obtained or verifying the property's condition, each contingency is a safeguard. With the market showing signs of activity after a quiet period, as noted by Larry Cerqua, Chair of CREAM, it's more important than ever to be diligent during the contingency period. The national average sale price has seen a 3.5% increase over the past year, and transaction numbers are rising. This makes it imperative to have a clear understanding of the property you're interested in and to make well-informed decisions.

Flowchart: Home-buying process during the contingency period

Can a House Under Contract Be Sold to Another Buyer?

Navigating the intricate pathways of property purchase can sometimes lead to unexpected legal quandaries. Take, for instance, the saga of a Gold Coast residence that recently fetched a staggering $2.66 million at auction.

This property's journey to sale was anything but ordinary; it was ensnared in a protracted five-year legal tussle. The crux of the matter?

The title had never been officially transferred to the supposed new owners, Jess and Jackie Morecroft, who had acquired the house at a mortgagee auction for $1.265 million back in 2018. Fast forward to February, and the Supreme Court decreed the house still belonged to the original owner due to the title transfer never being finalized.

This case underscores the paramount importance of ensuring all legal documentation is thoroughly vetted and executed correctly in property transactions. A word to the wise from legal expert Antonia Brandes, partner at Gunnercooke, concerning the period between exchange and completion: buyers may be oblivious to the alarming reality that they are obligated to pay the full price even for a property that has sustained damage during this interlude.

Prior regulations offered an escape clause, allowing buyers to withdraw if the property became uninhabitable post-exchange. Now, Brandes advises, buyers should assertively negotiate the transfer of risk to the seller before contract signing.

While solicitors may balk, it's unlikely a seller would risk derailing the sale over this. The Law Society acknowledges the difficulty buyers face in meeting insurers' demands to safeguard a property while it remains under the seller's dominion. In today's market, with the National Association of Realtors reporting a mere 2.9-month supply of available homes nationally, the stakes are high. Real estate contracts may contain contingencies to protect the seller, but complexities arise when buyers include sale contingencies. Such clauses hinge the purchase on the sale of the buyer's current home, potentially leaving the seller in limbo. In essence, while it's uncommon for a house under contract to be sold to another buyer, these examples illustrate that legal and contractual nuances can indeed make it a possibility.

Flowchart: Property Purchase Process

Navigating the intricacies of property transactions requires a keen understanding of legal disclosures, especially when unforeseen circumstances arise. For instance, sellers are obligated to provide candid details about the property's condition through a seller's disclosure form.

This document is pivotal in states where it's legally mandated, as it informs potential buyers about the property's history, structural integrity, and any known defects. Yet, it's important to recognize that regulations vary by state; for example, Massachusetts does not mandate these forms, but sellers must still disclose information like the presence of lead paint or septic systems.

Legal experts, like Antonia Brandes from Gunnercooke, highlight the risks buyers face when a property is damaged post-exchange but pre-completion. The national conditions of sale have shifted the responsibility to buyers, and Brandes advises insisting on seller accountability before signing contracts.

Transparency remains paramount, with a necessity for open communication about any conflicts of interest, commission structures, and material changes that could influence decision-making. The concept of 'caveat emptor' or 'buyer beware' still holds in many cases, yet exceptions exist. For example, a New York case revealed a seller's 'active concealment' of water damage, which the court deemed potentially fraudulent. Buyers should be thorough in their investigations and seek copies of closing documents for complete records. In the end, providing precise and honest information in the seller's disclosure ensures legal compliance and a transparent selling process, bolstering the buyer's confidence in their investment.

Flowchart: Property Transaction Process

Conclusion

In conclusion, entering into a contract on a home is a critical step that requires meticulous attention to legalities. The recent case on the Gold Coast, where a house was sold for $2.66 million following a five-year court battle, highlights the importance of thoroughness.

During the contingency period, buyers must conduct a home inspection, review the seller's disclosure statement, and confirm necessary permits. These steps protect their interests and help avoid unexpected costs in the future.

While uncommon, it is possible for a house under contract to be sold to another buyer due to legal and contractual nuances. Awareness of these complexities is crucial in today's competitive housing market.

Legal considerations and disclosures are significant in property transactions. Sellers must provide transparent information through disclosure forms, ensuring buyers have all necessary details about the property's condition.

Buyers should also prioritize seller accountability regarding damage that may occur before completion. By addressing legal aspects diligently, buyers can secure successful purchases and protect their investments. Seeking professional guidance throughout the process will provide confidence in navigating the real estate market. In summary, attention to legalities is vital when entering into a contract on a home. Thoroughness during the contingency period and awareness of potential complexities will help buyers make informed decisions and avoid pitfalls. By prioritizing transparency and seeking professional advice, buyers can confidently navigate the property transaction process and safeguard their investments.

Ensure a smooth and secure property transaction process by prioritizing thoroughness and staying aware of potential complexities. Contact Placy today to access comprehensive information and personalized assistance throughout your buying journey.

Read next